A Twitter thread that recently surfaced on social media has sparked the discussion back on a new and improved engagement ring expectations vs financial responsibility in relationships debate. The conversation began when a 24-year-old man on Reddit posed a question regarding his proposal plans, revealing his request for his girlfriend to pay for her own engagement ring. That’s why his experience struck a chord with so many, as the stories of disillusionment and bewilderment poured in on social media and other platforms.
The young man’s girlfriend took to Reddit to share her dismay after he told her she should pay for the ring. Though she admired the beauty of the proposed piece, she didn’t find it compelling in a personal way. She said, ‘I love it, it’s beautiful, it’s not my ring,’ ” she recalls. If so, she expressed a sentiment that was heard ‘round the internet as other women jumped online to share their own cringeworthy proposal experiences.
In another touching tale, 34-year-old Asia Frances of Philadelphia described how her proposal went down. Her partner offered her a bauble set in a cluster ring, and an unusual “shut-up” piece of jewelry, a silver trinket that was encrusted with a blanket of small 0.01-carat diamond chips. As Frances later reflected on her disappointment, “I was just so bummed out.” Her narrative sheds light on a shared, beautiful, and understandable exasperation among women with the importance and meaning behind engagement rings.
The 24-year-old Redditor opened up to us about his experience. During our interview he shared that he is really experiencing class issues, judging himself unfavorably against his girlfriend, who has a good income. “The problem is, I really don’t have a lot of money and my [girlfriend] has a good salary,” he mentioned. He felt it was fair to require her to pay part of her engagement ring herself. After all, they would in time be pooling their money together. Given that our money is going to be pooled eventually, I wondered if she would cover the cost of her engagement ring, he shared.
His girlfriend wasn’t on board with this defeatist attitude. She explained that she considered the request to reduce the ring something that cheapened this sentiment and expression of their love and commitment. This seemed common sense and a no brainer not to get approved. I thought I was wrong,” he finished, disclosing his dismay at how it turned out.
The discussion was further refocused by the tale of Bella Blake, a young Instagram influencer from Tennessee. See how Blake’s heartbreaking journey led her to learn the truth. Her groom had proposed with a ring he’d made for his former fiancée. That realization broke her heart, exposing the emotional complexity connected to engagement rings and their symbolic value in our culture’s romantic relationships.
As these narratives develop on social media, they disrupt what people expect from engagement. More importantly, they reflect the new reality that partnerships are changing in America today. Few of us would think that financial equity should dictate when we reach major life milestones. Some argue the emotional weight of these symbols should trump everything else.
Leave a Reply