A global commission has proposed a redefinition of obesity assessment, challenging the long-standing reliance on Body Mass Index (BMI) as the primary metric. The commission's report suggests that the traditional approach, which calculates obesity by dividing a person's weight in kilograms by the square of their height in meters, does not fully capture the health risks associated with obesity. The commission advocates for a more nuanced method that considers additional factors such as waist circumference, body fat percentage, and obesity-related health conditions.
Currently, most individuals undergo a brief 15-minute appointment for obesity assessment, often resulting in a diagnosis based solely on BMI. Despite this, the commission does not recommend abolishing BMI; rather, it proposes redefining its role in conjunction with other indicators. This change aims to provide a more comprehensive understanding of obesity, which affects over 100 million American adults and is linked to chronic health issues like heart disease and type 2 diabetes.
Insurance companies typically base coverage decisions on BMI, a practice that has been controversial for years. Dr. Siegel notes, "In the majority of people, BMI can diagnose obesity, but this is trying to see if something better can be done." The existing system may misdiagnose some individuals due to its simplicity, as Siegel adds, "BMI is really easy to calculate in the clinic, and it will misdiagnose some people."
Some doctors have already begun adjusting their diagnostic methods to incorporate additional metrics. The proposed changes by the commission have garnered support from 76 organizations worldwide. Katherine N. Balantekin, PhD, RD, emphasizes the complexity of obesity by defining it as "a complex, chronic disease characterized by an excessive accumulation of body fat that impairs health."
Under the new model, individuals with a BMI over 25 and no immediate health issues would receive monitoring and counseling to prevent weight gain. For a clinical obesity diagnosis, patients would need a BMI at or near 30, accompanied by other measures such as a high waist circumference and any medical conditions caused by obesity. For instance, women with a waist measurement exceeding 34.6 inches and men with at least 40 inches are likely to have excess body fat.
Healthcare providers may face increased challenges with this approach, as it requires more time and precision in diagnosis. However, Keerthana Kesavarapu, DO, believes that "this will be better for patients," ensuring a more accurate reflection of their health status. She further adds, "This could be very good for everyone in the long run."
The commission's recommendations aim to promote better health outcomes by recognizing individuals with excess body weight who may not present immediate health concerns. Siegel acknowledges, "There are a number of people with excess body weight and they’re perfectly happy."
The shift in obesity assessment could have significant implications for insurance coverage. Siegel remarks on this potential change, stating, "We will have to see if insurance will change, too—and that will probably take several years."
Leave a Reply