Mark Rowlands, a professor and chair of the Department of Philosophy at the University of Miami, has spent over a decade living with a wolf and is a serial dog owner. He shares an intriguing perspective on the inner world of dogs and their ability to experience joy. According to Rowlands, dogs love their lives far more deeply than humans do, due to their lack of reflective self-awareness—a trait that often burdens humans.
Rowlands suggests that while humans are plagued by reflection and doubt, dogs live fully in the moment. This difference stems from the fact that dogs are both actors and authors of their lives, not mere spectators or critics. In contrast, humans, as posited by philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre, can become crippled by reflective self-awareness.
"Dogs love their lives more than we love ours. That is why their lives are more meaningful than ours." – Mark Rowlands
Rowlands elaborates on this by stating that humans essentially lead two lives: one that is vibrant and another that is overshadowed by reflection. This duality can make it challenging for people to find meaning in life. He argues that dogs, with their singular focus, love their lives with an unmatched passion.
"A dog only has one life, and of it he is actor and not spectator, author and not critic." – Mark Rowlands
Rowlands' observations are largely drawn from his experiences with his German shepherd, Shadow. Despite Shadow's aggressive behavior—such as fighting with other dogs and urinating on occupied park benches—he experiences immense pleasure from simple acts like chasing sunbathing iguanas. Rowlands compares Shadow's relentless pursuit of happiness to the myth of Sisyphus, who was condemned to push a boulder up a hill only for it to roll back down.
"A dog loves his life with everything he has because it is all he has." – Mark Rowlands
Rowlands asserts that dogs derive happiness from their deepest nature. They find meaning in life through genuine moments of joy, unencumbered by the complexities of human reflection. He concludes that a dog's life is more meaningful than a human's because humans have been fractured by reflection into two lives of dubious compatibility.
"Meaning in life exists wherever happiness erupts from nature. If you want to know the meaning of life, get a dog." – Mark Rowlands
"Finding meaning in life is hard for us, but easy for dogs." – Mark Rowlands
Leave a Reply